DECONSTRUCTING THE HISTORICAL NARRATIVE: A CRITICAL REVIEW OF THE ABSENCE OF A CONSTRUCTIVE ROLE OF THE SHIA FACTION IN THE PAST, PRESENT, AND FUTURE OF ISLAMIC CIVILIZATION

• Rizaldy Alpiansyah

  Sekolah Tinggi Agama Islam Minhajul Haq

  Author

  https://orcid.org/0009-0008-9505-8673

• Isrun Abdurahman

  Sekolah Tinggi Agama Islam Minhajul Haq

  Author

• Irfan Alkhotiri

  Sekolah Tinggi Agama Islam Minhajul Haq

  Author

  https://orcid.org/0009-0008-5137-0737

• Miftah Wangsadanureja

  STIQ ZAD Cianjur

  Author

• Dzulfikri

  University of Bakhtalruda

  Author

The discourse on the history of Islamic civilization is often dominated by narratives that romanticize inter-group harmony without giving adequate attention to a critical analysis of the disintegrative factions within it. This scientific article aims to examine, dissect, and deconstruct the claims regarding the Shia faction's contributions to achieving the glory of Islam. This study investigates the historical role, contemporary sociopolitical reality, and future projections of the Shia faction using a comparative-analytical (muqāran) historical approach based on orthodox classical literature and modern political studies. The results conclusively show that the absence of a positive Shia role is not an a priori assumption, but a well-documented historical fact. In the past, the existence of Shia political entities such as the Fatimid (Ubaydid) Dynasty in Egypt and the Safavid Dynasty in Persia consistently acted as subversive forces that destroyed the cohesion of the Ummah, hindered the expansion of Islam into Europe by allying with Christian empires, and facilitated the collapse of the Abbasid Caliphate in Baghdad in 1258 AD. At present, the theological anomalies inherent in Shia dogma—such as the exclusive Imamate cult, the doctrine of infallibility, and the rejection of the legitimacy of the early generations of the Prophet's Companions—have triggered severe creedal clashes. The transformation of this ideology into a political movement post-1979 Iranian Revolution has proven to spawn sectarian proxy wars that destroy the infrastructure of civilization in the Middle East and threaten social harmony in regions like Indonesia. Projecting into the future, this research concludes that the historical shackles and sectarian sentiments institutionalized in Shia theology will always be a stumbling block to the reconciliation of the Ummah. As long as the epistemology of hatred towards mainstream history is maintained, the Shia faction will remain an inhibiting variable that distances the Ummah from the ideals of unity and the revival of global Islamic civilization.

Al-Dhahabi & Al-Safadi, in the historical analysis of Ibn Taymiyyah and Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyyah. Criticism of Khwajah Nasir al-Din al-Tusi and the fall of Baghdad. A review of the role of betrayal in the collapse of the Abbasid institution.6

Arsyad Haikal, M. (2025). Consolidation of Shia History in the Classical Era: A Critical Study of Al-Qummi's Interpretation. Abhats: Jurnal Studi Keislaman, UII.11

Balai Litbang Agama Semarang. (2012). Shia: History of Emergence and Its Development in Indonesia. Jurnal Harmoni Kemenag.8

Cahyono, Aji, & Ridwan, Muchamad. (2022). Shia and Sunni Islam in the Era of the Safavid Dynasty and the Dynamics of Their Conflicts. JIIR: Jurnal Ilmu-Ilmu Sosial.4

Dewan Hisbah Persatuan Islam (Persis). (2012). Fatwa on the Deviation of Shia and Views of Persis Figures Toward the Creedal Pollution of Shia (K.H. Shidiq Aminullah, M. Natsir, et al.). Publikasi Berita Resmi Persis.12

Gharib, Abdullah Muh. (1984). The Essence of Shia. Pustaka Mantiq, Solo. LPPI Reference & History of Shia Development in Indonesia.8

Hitti, Philip K. (1974). History of The Arabs. The MacMillan Press Ltd. In reference to the history of the Ubaydid/Fatimid Dynasty.5

Lapidus, Ira M. (1999). A History of Islamic Societies. Translated by Ghufron A. Mas'adi. Rajawali Press, Jakarta.20

Majelis Ulama Indonesia (MUI). (1984). MUI Recommendation on the Principal Creedal Differences Between Imamiyyah Shia and Ahlus Sunnah Wal Jamaah in Indonesia.8

Syafii Maarif, Ahmad. (2023). Sunni-Shia as the Shackles of History: Unraveling the Internal Conflict of the Muslim Ummah. Maarif: Arus Pemikiran Islam dan Sosial.9

Suryanti. (2017). The Mongol Nation Established the Islamic-Based Ilkhanid Dynasty Following the Destruction of Baghdad in 1258-1347. Nalar: Jurnal Peradaban dan Pemikiran Islam.7

Taufani. (2023). Unraveling Ahmad Syafii Maarif's Thoughts on the Internal Conflict of the Muslim Ummah. Jurnal Studi Sektarianisme.9

Wahid Foundation. (2018). National Survey Report on the Trends of Socio-Religious Tolerance and the Most Disliked Groups in Indonesia (October 2017 Period).9

Watt, W. Montgomery. (1999). Classical Islamic Study: Discourse on Historical Criticism. Tiara Wacana, Yogyakarta. In the study of political power and Islamic sect domination.3

Yatim, Badri. (2002). History of Islamic Civilization. Raja Grafindo Persada, Jakarta.3

WORKS CITED

1. Islamic Golden Age - Wikipedia, diakses Maret 27, 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_Golden_Age

2. Sunni dan Syiah: Dinamika Sejarah dan Tantangan dalam Membangun Peradaban Islam Global, diakses Maret 27, 2026, https://ejournal.uin-suka.ac.id/adab/thaqafiyyat/article/download/3772/1385

3. SEJARAH KEMUNCULAN DAN PERKEMBANGAN SYI'AH, diakses Maret 27, 2026, https://jurnaliainpontianak.or.id/index.php/khatulistiwa/article/download/220/178

4. Islam dalam Pusaran Konflik: Syiah dan Sunni Era Dinasti Safawi, diakses Maret 27, 2026, https://jurnalfisip.uinsa.ac.id/index.php/JIIR/article/download/350/253/1490

5. DINASTI FATIMIYAH : ANALISIS KEMAJUAN DAN RUNTUHNYA ..., diakses Maret 27, 2026, https://ejournal.stitbima.ac.id/index.php/fitua/article/download/321/214/

6. Tuduhan Nasiruddin | PDF - Slideshare, diakses Maret 27, 2026, https://www.slideshare.net/slideshow/tuduhan-nasiruddin/1800329

7. PERADABAN ISLAM PADA MASA DINASTI SAFAWI DI PERSIA ..., diakses Maret 27, 2026, https://journal.an-nur.ac.id/index.php/annur/article/download/2023/1867/6858

8. Syiah: Sejarah Timbul dan Perkembangannya di Indonesia - Harmoni, diakses Maret 27, 2026, https://jurnalharmoni.kemenag.go.id/index.php/harmoni/article/download/253/211/537

9. SUNNI-SYIAH SEBAGAI BELENGGU SEJARAH ... - Jurnal Maarif, diakses Maret 27, 2026, https://jurnal-maarifinstitute.org/index.php/maarif/article/download/214/116/307

10. Contoh Jurnal Sinta Update 2025 | Arbain Publishing, diakses Maret 27, 2026, https://blog.arbain.co.id/contoh-jurnal-sinta/

11. Consolidation of Shia History in the Classical Era: A ... - Journal UII, diakses Maret 27, 2026, https://journal.uii.ac.id/Abhats/article/download/44077/19121

12. Pandangan Persis terhadap Syiah - Portal Persatuan Islam (PERSIS), diakses Maret 27, 2026, https://persis.or.id/News/read/pandangan-persis-terhadap-syiah

13. View of SYIAH: SEJARAH TIMBUL DAN PERKEMBANGANNYA DI ..., diakses Maret 27, 2026, https://jurnalharmoni.kemenag.go.id/index.php/harmoni/article/view/253/211

14. View of Sunni-Syiah sebagai Belenggu Sejarah: Mengurai Pemikiran Ahmad Syafii Maarif tentang Konflik Internal Umat Islam, diakses Maret 27, 2026, https://jurnal-maarifinstitute.org/index.php/maarif/article/view/214/116

15. DINASTI FATHIMIYAH DI MESIR (Analisa Pertumbuhan, Perkembangan dan Pengaruhnya) - Jurnal, diakses Maret 27, 2026, https://jurnal.pancabudi.ac.id/index.php/alhadi/article/download/150/132/

16. Filsafat Sosial-Politik Nasiruddin Al-Tusi | PDF | Ilmu Sosial | Agama & Spiritualitas - Scribd, diakses Maret 27, 2026, https://id.scribd.com/doc/28853800/Nasrudin-Al-Thusi

17. Kritik & solusi syiah di indonesia | PDF - Slideshare, diakses Maret 27, 2026, https://www.slideshare.net/slideshow/kritik-solusi-syiah-di-indonesia/28183562

18. PERKEMBANGAN TEOLOGI DAN DINAMIKA SOSIAL ALIRAN SYIAH DALAM SEJARAH ISLAM, diakses Maret 27, 2026, https://rel.ojs.co.id/index.php/jkai/article/download/191/218/404

19. Sunni-Syiah sebagai Belenggu Sejarah: Mengurai Pemikiran Ahmad Syafii Maarif tentang Konflik Internal Umat Islam - ResearchGate, diakses Maret 27, 2026, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/371797620_Sunni-Syiah_sebagai_Belenggu_Sejarah_Mengurai_Pemikiran_Ahmad_Syafii_Maarif_tentang_Konflik_Internal_Umat_Islam

20. SEJARAH DAN PERADABAN ISLAM DINASTI SAFAWI DI PERSIA - Al-Manba, diakses Maret 27, 2026, https://e-journal.stai-almaarif-buntok.ac.id/index.php/almanba/article/download/8/7

21. ENHANCING COMMUNITY LEGAL LITERACY AS AN EFFORT TO OVERCOME THE WEAKNESSES OF THE CONSUMER PROTECTION SYSTEM IN GOODS PURCHASE TRANSACTIONS (R. Alpiansyah, I. Alkhotiri, & Harsing, Trans.). (2026). Al Musa’adah : Journal of Community Service STAI Minhajul Haq, 1(1), 1-10. https://doi.org/10.66891/4r7z1x04

22. INTEGRATIVE BASKETBALL PERIODIZATION AND ADAB-BASED CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT: AN EMPIRICAL STUDY OF THE EXTRACURRICULAR PROGRAM AT PONPES MINHAJUL HAQ PURWAKARTA (R. Alpiansyah, A. Salim, & Muslihin, Trans.). (2026). Al Musa’adah : Journal of Community Service STAI Minhajul Haq, 1(1), 37-48. https://doi.org/10.66891/s0nedt19

• PDF